Late
Summer-Early Fall. Unknown parentage. Mercer, Somerset County,
ME, before 1850. Also known as Somerset. I thought this apple was
the discovery of early Mercer settler John Thompson, but now believe
it to have originated on the farm of AJ Downs, another early resident.
A large oblate excellent-flavored eating and cooking apple. Tender,
juicy and subacid. Buttery yellow skin covered with stripes and wash
of rusty red. In the 1907 Maine Agricultural Experiment Station Report,
WM Munson wrote, "It is an excellent apple and, when known, is
highly prized as an early market variety." The late Edward Bobalek,
fruit collector and Orono professor, described it as a summer apple
with the flesh and flavor of a winter fruit. Will keep into late fall.
Very vigorous, spreading tree. When I was up in Abbot this past spring
a number of older people wanted to know about this apple. Apparently
Somerset was brought there over 100 years ago from Mercer and has
been a local favorite ever since. Our scionwood came from Glen Harris's
tree in Mercer via our friend Bill Reid's New Sharon orchard.
The name Somerset of Maine has been often attached
to another very different, distinctly conical-shaped Maine summer
apple called Thompson. Thompson also originated in the same town
(see below) and has in turn been regularly confused with the Massachusetts
apple, Williams which it closely resembles. The result is a confusion
that dates back to the 19th century and persists today even in Mercer
itself. You can see a rather obvious example of the confusion in
the description of Somerset in George Stilphen's recent book, The
Apples of Maine. There he includes both contradictory descriptions
under the same apple.
I believe the problem arose in about 1849 when the
Kennebec Agricultural Society first used the name Somerset of Maine
to describe what must be Thompson because they compare it to Williams
and Porter in shape. The Somerset described in Downing's Fruits
and Fruit Trees of America and in Thomas' The American Fruit Culturist
is not at all like Porter or Williams. This confusion was probably
further aggravated by the existence of another apple called simply
Somerset that originated in New York that does resemble Porter and
Williams. What Thomas and Downing as well as W.M. Munson of Maine
were describing is most certainly this apple that originated on
A.J. Downs' farm. The Mercer orchardist and collector Francis Fenton
of Mercer, has both apples in his orchard. He attributes the name
Somerset to Downs' oblate apple and the name Thompson to the conic
summer apple. I believe Fenton is correct, but others in town still
disagree. |